| Middle Island to Plattsburgh (New York) | 264.47 mi (425.63 km) |
| Middle Island to Pleasant Grove (Utah) | 2,017.79 mi (3,247.32 km) |
| Middle Island to Pleasant Hill (California) | 2,595.67 mi (4,177.33 km) |
| Middle Island to Pleasant Hill (Iowa) | 1,066.31 mi (1,716.06 km) |
| Middle Island to Pleasant Prairie (Wisconsin) | 778.10 mi (1,252.23 km) |
| Middle Island to Pleasant View (Utah) | 2,016.10 mi (3,244.60 km) |
| Middle Island to Pleasanton (California) | 2,592.64 mi (4,172.44 km) |
| Middle Island to Pleasanton (Texas) | 1,656.29 mi (2,665.54 km) |
| Middle Island to Pleasantville (New Jersey) | 132.55 mi (213.31 km) |
| Middle Island to Plover (Wisconsin) | 876.59 mi (1,410.74 km) |
| Middle Island to Plum (Pennsylvania) | 357.34 mi (575.08 km) |
| Middle Island to Plymouth (Indiana) | 696.16 mi (1,120.36 km) |
| Middle Island to Plymouth (Minnesota) | 1,072.87 mi (1,726.61 km) |
| Middle Island to Pocatello (Idaho) | 2,018.95 mi (3,249.19 km) |
| Middle Island to Poinciana (Florida) | 1,005.74 mi (1,618.58 km) |
