| Middle Island to Payson (Arizona) | 2,133.33 mi (3,433.27 km) |
| Middle Island to Payson (Utah) | 2,023.36 mi (3,256.28 km) |
| Middle Island to Peabody (Massachusetts) | 152.69 mi (245.73 km) |
| Middle Island to Peachtree City (Georgia) | 822.09 mi (1,323.02 km) |
| Middle Island to Peachtree Corners (Georgia) | 781.21 mi (1,257.24 km) |
| Middle Island to Pearl (Mississippi) | 1,119.04 mi (1,800.92 km) |
| Middle Island to Pearl City (Hawaii) | 5,011.89 mi (8,065.85 km) |
| Middle Island to Pearl River (New York) | 56.58 mi (91.05 km) |
| Middle Island to Pearland (Texas) | 1,479.17 mi (2,380.50 km) |
| Middle Island to Pebble Creek (Florida) | 1,027.78 mi (1,654.05 km) |
| Middle Island to Pecan Grove (Texas) | 1,495.95 mi (2,407.50 km) |
| Middle Island to Pecos (Texas) | 1,816.16 mi (2,922.83 km) |
| Middle Island to Peekskill (New York) | 58.00 mi (93.35 km) |
| Middle Island to Pekin (Illinois) | 872.32 mi (1,403.86 km) |
| Middle Island to Pelham (Alabama) | 921.91 mi (1,483.67 km) |
