| Middle Island to Isabela (Puerto Rico) | 1,586.08 mi (2,552.55 km) |
| Middle Island to Iselin (New Jersey) | 75.07 mi (120.82 km) |
| Middle Island to Isla Vista (California) | 2,574.04 mi (4,142.51 km) |
| Middle Island to Issaquah (Washington) | 2,432.75 mi (3,915.13 km) |
| Middle Island to Ithaca (New York) | 212.85 mi (342.56 km) |
| Middle Island to Ives Estates (Florida) | 1,111.26 mi (1,788.40 km) |
| Middle Island to Jackson (Michigan) | 599.26 mi (964.42 km) |
| Middle Island to Jackson (Mississippi) | 1,122.92 mi (1,807.16 km) |
| Middle Island to Jackson (Missouri) | 925.97 mi (1,490.20 km) |
| Middle Island to Jackson (Tennessee) | 932.92 mi (1,501.38 km) |
| Middle Island to Jackson (Wyoming) | 1,928.44 mi (3,103.52 km) |
| Middle Island to Jacksonville (Alabama) | 855.34 mi (1,376.54 km) |
| Middle Island to Jacksonville (Arkansas) | 1,122.50 mi (1,806.49 km) |
| Middle Island to Jacksonville (Florida) | 877.65 mi (1,412.44 km) |
| Middle Island to Jacksonville (Illinois) | 912.81 mi (1,469.02 km) |
